© 2026 NEW MEXICO NEWS SERVICES 9/21/26
Pay our legislators and demand ethical behavior: Support Constitutional Amendment 4
By Sherry Robinson
All She Wrote
After years of debate, voters will have the chance to weigh in on a paid Legislature in Constitutional Amendment 4. In all the pros and cons so far, however, nobody has raised the big question: Who benefits by having volunteer legislators?
Supporters (mostly Democrats) have long maintained that paying lawmakers would open the field to people who can’t afford to serve now. In rural areas, I would add, the candidates are often the only people who can afford to be without a paycheck during legislative sessions. Paying lawmakers would make races more competitive and recognize the time they put in all year long.
Opponents (mostly Republicans) argue that it rewards lawmakers for not solving the state’s problems and prompts some candidates to run just for the paycheck.
Since 2023 New Mexico has been the last state in the nation with an unpaid Legislature, an outlier status we’ve held for years. Opponents have defeated ballot measures many times, and legislators themselves have often been opposed.
It’s time to ask who benefits from this arrangement? One answer is: People who can reap the unpaid benefits and connections of being a legislator.
Lawyers, for example. In private practice they can arrange their own schedules, and the perception of being connected brings more clients in the door. The higher they rank in the legislative hierarchy, the greater the benefit. This has been true since I first covered the Roundhouse in the days when Raymond Sanchez and Manny Aragon were House and Senate honchos. It’s no accident that the same leadership roles are still held by lawyers; if you could peer into the books of the House Speaker and Senate Majority Leader you would probably find they’ve done well for themselves.
Add to this category self-employed folks, such as real estate and insurance agents, marketers, consultants and the like. How many deals come their way because they have access to people and information?
A second category of people who benefit are those who work for large organizations that enable them to serve because it benefits the organization.
One example is Sheryl Williams Stapleton, the former House Majority Leader whose corruption trial just ended. Stapleton worked for Albuquerque Public Schools. For years, Stapleton and APS were the 800-pound gorilla in any education debate, and she was effectively an APS lobbyist. The outcomes didn’t necessarily favor smaller districts. I covered such stories.
Not every lawmaker is self-serving, of course, but our current system makes us dependent on “volunteers” who may have irons in the fire. Who, exactly, are they serving? As former Sen. Dede Feldman wrote in 2014, “Almost every day, legislators are called upon to vote on issues that have a financial effect on them.”
Conflicts of interest have always been with us, but in recent years it seems worse.
The most egregious was the trial lawyers’ 2021 change in state law that targeted doctors, clinics and hospitals. Trial lawyers tried to kill the medical malpractice reform bill; failing that because of public outrage, they severely limited the reform. And one doctor-suing trial lawyer killed bills to ease our doctor shortage before the Senate Judiciary Committee, chaired by another trial lawyer who sues doctors. That same chairman persuaded his buddy, the Senate Majority Leader, to carry a bill creating a new judgeship to hear the rising tide of medical malpractice and personal injury cases. That would have cost taxpayers more than $450,000. It died on bad publicity.
I’ve been shocked at how blatant and shameless it all is. Aren’t they required to recuse themselves when they have a conflict?
In a new report from the nonpartisan, good-government group Think New Mexico, we learn there are no rules. The state Constitution gives each legislative chamber the power to regulate voting and recusal. Not only that, the chamber insists on a vote even when conflicts are apparent.
“New Mexico’s approach is at odds with the practices of most other states,” according to the report. And the group’s survey in August found that 81% of New Mexico voters wanted legislators to recuse themselves when they had a conflict of interest.
Ethics experts have told us for some time now that unpaid legislative service and conflicts of interest go hand in hand; in New Mexico we wink at bad behavior because they work for free. “The volunteer status of New Mexico’s legislature has long ben cited as the primary reason for the state’s relatively lax approach to ethical requirements,” the report says.
In other words, if we were paying them, we would insist on ethical standards.
The full proposal calls for a salary of about $67,800, the state’s gross median annual household income, beginning in 2029. That’s about $7.6 million a year. The amount would be adjusted annually. It may be a median, but in this state that sounds like a lot of money for alternating 60- and 30-day sessions and interim meetings. And the salary would be on top of per diem and pension benefits. Opponents don’t like it.
But let’s remember that this is just part of needed reforms. Sixty days are inadequate to hear and vet complex bills, and 30 days are a bad joke. Other states pay their legislators and hold longer sessions.
Constituents are fed up. I believe the same public outrage can fuel the entire reform. As I’ve said before, slapdash governance from unpaid lawmakers during short sessions is one of the reasons New Mexico stays poor.
© 2026 NEW MEXICO NEWS SERVICES 9/16/26
Fans flexed their muscles to save “Coyote vs. Acme”
By Sherry Robinson
All She Wrote
I always thought of Wile E. Coyote and Roadrunner as New Mexican. After all, we have the vast desertscapes and endless roads depicted in the cartoons, and the roadrunner is our state bird. But “Coyote vs. Acme” made it official. Coyote gets his day in court, and it’s a New Mexico courthouse.
Filmed in Albuquerque and on Jemez and Zia Pueblo lands in spring 2022, the production employed about 180 New Mexico crew members, 49 New Mexico principal actors and some 2,120 New Mexicans as background talent, according to the state Film Office. Thanks to the insistence of those crew members, Albuquerque could play itself instead of standing in for Phoenix as initially planned. As they pointed out, Bugs Bunny had joked for years, “I shoulda taken that left turn at Albuquerque.”
In this zany movie’s marriage of animation and live action, those of us who grew up with Looney Tunes characters get to see many of them on full display and with some new personas. For the most part, we’re treated to sheer entertainment from the cartoon and human cast, but the film does dip into a few serious themes: Coyote as the dissatisfied consumer, Acme as the untouchable corporate giant, Coyote and his billboard lawyer (Will Forte) as underdogs.
And there’s resentment of the rich and powerful. In one scene, Coyote deploys a Rube Goldberg device that imprisons Acme CEO Foghorn Leghorn and his slick corporate lawyer (John Cena). The lawyer shouts, “Do you know how much I’m worth?”
In a twist that could have been part of the movie, “Coyote vs. Acme” almost didn’t reach the big screen because of a foolish corporate decision.
The movie was scheduled for release in July 2023. Its makers had invested much love in the project and worked hard, said the director, "to honor the legacies of these historic characters and actually get them right." Despite praise during test screenings and interest from buyers, Warner Bros. released “Barbie” instead and shelved “Coyote” to claim a tax loss during some cost-cutting after its merger with Discovery.
The decision blindsided crew members, according to multiple media and trade reports, and sparked a storm of criticism within the industry. But in November 2023 Warner reversed its decision and allowed filmmakers to shop “Coyote” to other distributors. There was interest from Paramount, Netflix and Amazon, but Warner rejected their bids; nobody was willing to meet Warner’s price, and the company again threatened to shelve the film. The hashtags #ReleaseCoyoteVsAcme and #SaveCoyoteVsAcme and others were trending for weeks in early 2024.
Will Forte released a public statement addressed to the cast and crew: "Please know that all the years and years of hard work, dedication and love that you put into this movie shows in every frame." Not until March 2025 did Ketchup Entertainment acquire the film and announce its release this year.
That’s why this statement appears at the end of the film’s credits: “Dedicated to everyone who posted, shared, held up signs and spoke out when it counted. This film made it to the big screen because of you.”
“Coyote vs. Acme” is getting its revenge at the box office. In the first two weeks after its release, it had earned $39.9 million at the domestic box office and $50.89 million worldwide. Compare this with the $30 million Warner thought it was worth as a tax write-off. As many a reviewer has written, it also demonstrates the power of fan support.
The comeback of “Coyote” is also a bright note to New Mexico’s film industry, which has suffered a long dry spell that began with the writer’s strike in 2023. The downturn continued as the United States lose productions to places like Bulgaria that can offer lower costs, cheaper labor and competitive incentives. In addition, streaming platforms have changed.
At a recent conference sponsored by the New Mexico Film Office, one expert said production spending between 2022 and 2025 was down 60% in New Mexico, reported the Albuquerque Journal. On the other hand, Netflix brass revealed that “something big is coming, and we’re thrilled about it.” The union rep promised, “Work is coming. Shows are starting up.”
Speakers were also cheered by a post from President Trump supporting a national film production incentive.
Film industry professionals have shown they’re a tenacious bunch, staying the course even if they have to take side gigs to pay the bills. It’s not unlike our hero Wile E. Coyote who never gives up no matter how many falling anvils, ill-timed explosives and dislodged boulders come his way.
© 2026 NEW MEXICO NEWS SERVICES 9/9/26
‘We could get rid of the personal income tax.’
By Sherry Robinson
All She Wrote
Republicans have floated a proposal to repeal the state’s personal income tax, but they’ve relied more on platitudes than hard numbers to justify their position. So I went to the mountain to talk to the Wise Man. That would be Sen. George Muñoz, chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, who is also one of the Legislature’s few businessmen.
It’s possible, he says. “It would cost $2.5 billion to get rid of it.”
Muñoz sees this and other tax-related issues through one lens: How do we put real money in people’s pockets?
Lawmakers have tried to do this but aren’t always successful. For example, they tried reducing the gross receipts tax that we all pay on goods and services, but this tax has two actors – state and local governments. The state can reduce its share, but local governments will raise theirs because they rely on this tax.
Muñoz counts the working family tax credit as a success “because you have to work to get it.” And even though he was initially annoyed that the governor foisted free childcare on the Legislature without discussion, he’s now on board because it saves families $7,000 a year. “That puts real money in their pockets.”
Muñoz turns to the big numbers. Here we have a good news-bad news-good news scenario.
In August economists estimated that state revenues, which jumped between 2023 and 2025, will keep climbing for the next three years, from $14 billion in fiscal 2026 to $14.8 billion in fiscal 2028. That means “new money,” or general funds available for spending, will shoot up to $924.2 million in fiscal 2028. This is because the Iran war is driving up oil prices.
If that was the whole story we could celebrate, but national and state data paint a “more troubling” picture, according to Legislative Finance Committee economists. The labor market, nationally and statewide, has weakened sharply. Inflation is crushing household budgets. For the most vulnerable, expiring subsidies for Affordable Care Act premiums and Medicaid funding reductions add more strain. The U.S. economy, as economists keep telling us, only looks good because some companies are investing in AI, and wealthy consumers are spending, but tariffs, immigration restrictions and the war are a drag on growth.
Next Muñoz turns to the different sources of revenue.
“Look at investment revenue,” he says. “In 2022 we started putting real money in there.”
Legislators deserve a lot of credit for not squandering the state’s oil bonanza and instead steering extra money into various trust funds that get invested and reward us with returns. Some is designated for such special funds as the Early Childhood Trust Fund and the Medicaid Trust Fund, but a great deal will flow into the general fund. From fiscal 2026 to fiscal 2030 the growth is 11.5%, “well over the long-term growth rates,” write LFC economists. And for the first time these earnings will exceed personal income taxes and become the second largest source of revenue starting in the next budget year.
This is where Muñoz sees a way to reduce or eliminate personal income taxes. As investment returns increase, the individual tax bite could decrease or go away without jeopardizing the state’s financial stability.
Muñoz hints that it could happen faster if lawmakers take a hard look at the state’s many economic-development tax breaks. A recent LFC report shows that many of them show little return or even cost the state.
“If we’re going to do this and put money in people’s pockets, let’s get rid of some taxes,” he says. “We could get rid of the personal income tax. That makes a difference.”
The question has sparked irrational commentary on both sides.
House Minority Leader Gail Armstron, without citing any supporting data, again demands that the governor call a special session to repeal the personal income tax. Special sessions are designed to be in and out. A decision of this magnitude will never be decided in a special session. It’s a political ploy to let voters know the Rs support income tax repeal.
Taxation and Revenue Department Secretary Stephanie Schardin Clarke countered that the lowest-earning 54% of taxpayers wouldn’t see that much tax relief, while the high earners would make out. A repeal would “blow a $2.2 billion hole in the state budget,” forcing painful cuts. This one doesn’t wash either. Who wouldn’t like to have more money left in their paycheck? And, as Muñoz points out, we’re within striking distance of being able to cover that $2.2 billion hole.
Paul Gessing, of the conservative Rio Grande Foundation, has proposed phasing out the income tax over a few years. “If revenues don’t keep up (say oil prices drop dramatically or the U.S. goes into a recession) those tax cuts can be reversed or put on hold,” he wrote.
Muñoz, a moderate Democrat, is already on board with a phase out but isn’t optimistic.
“You could start a phaseout,” he says, “but it’s not going to happen with a progressive administration.”
© 2026 NEW MEXICO NEWS SERVICES 8/31/26
Save our national parks!
By Sherry Robinson
All She Wrote
The first national park I ever visited was Carlsbad Caverns, and I doubt the Brownie camera I toted did justice to the underground wonder. My dad, a New Yorker who had loved the West ever since Uncle Sam’s army introduced him to it, took us to see all the wonders in driving distance. That’s what they could afford. And there was plenty to see.
I did the same. My active and curious son was smitten with the caverns. He took his own son to Carlsbad when the time came.
We’ve been repeat customers of all 15 national parks and monuments in New Mexico and closely involved with one, El Malpais National Monument and Conservation Area. My husband, as a young federal employee, did the legwork to get this one started and then managed the Bureau of Land Management’s half for years. I know firsthand all the time he and his co-workers put in off the clock. I know how much they cared. And I know how much the towns of Grants and Milan wanted this designation to put them on the tourist map. My first book was about El Malpais.
This year we celebrate 110 years of the National Park Service in the same year that the nation marks its 250thanniversary. We hear lofty words about national heritage, but the reality on the ground is far different.
The national parks are as popular as ever: 320 million people visited last year and spent $29 billion in communities near the parks, which supported 340,000 jobs and generated more than $56 billion in economic activity, wrote Sen. Martin Heinrich, D-NM.
And yet parks suffer from a $24 billion maintenance backlog – New Mexico’s portion of that is $213 million, Heinrich says – and lost a quarter of their staffing, more than 4,000 jobs, to DOGE and other cuts.
“Instead of working to address these maintenance needs and keep visitors safe and our parks accessible, the administration is making hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars available for the President’s vanity projects,” Heinrich said.
What Heinrich calls “vanity projects,” the president calls “beautification.”
This includes repairing ornamental fountains in Washington D.C. ($60 million); the disastrous, no-bid renovation of the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool ($16 million); covering horse statues in gold leaf ($5 million); replacing Tennessee flagstone paving the White House’s West Colonnade with polished African granite carved in Italy ($689,232); and replacing stucco on the Colonnade wall so the president could hang plaques with his opinions of U.S. presidents ($347,503).
Who’s paying for all this? The National Park Service, according to multiple media reports, and the price tag keeps rising. The NPS’s tab, says veteran D.C. journalist Scott McFarlane, is upwards of $323 million, some from park entrance fees and some from America the Beautiful Passes. (Trump wanted his picture next to George Washington’s on the pass.)
By law, at least 80% of recreation fees must be used for maintenance at the national park site where the fees were collected. No president has ever tapped park fees to support his own projects.
“That is not how it was designed to work,” said an official with the National Parks Conservation Association. “It shouldn’t just be all at one park at the expense of the entire national park system.”
At our national parks, visitors are seeing long lines, deteriorating roads and water systems, fewer ranger programs and tours, closed bathrooms, shorter hours, less habitat restoration, and less trail maintenance. Some parks, deprived of guardrail replacements and other safety infrastructure, are disasters waiting to happen.
It could get worse. For fiscal 2027 the administration wants to cut NPS discretionary funding for park operations by 32% and reduce an already decimated staff level by 18% to 13,119. Heinrich warned it would gut the scientists, archaeologists, and historians that parks rely on. The administration wants $10 billion for more D.C. beautification projects.
What would your family vote for? Gilded statues or ranger who can answer questions? Fancy pavers or park rangers?
Political science professor Robert Cropf, of St. Louis University, sees the NPS’s gradual decline as a deliberate strategy he calls “governing by neglect.”
“Visible cuts carry political risk,” but underfunding “avoids backlash that would come with openly targeting popular institutions like national parks,” he wrote in The Fulcrum. Fewer rangers and longer lines may only feel like an inconvenience or the cost of popularity. “But it is something else: the visible edge of a deeper shift in how the country governs its shared resources.”
© 2026 NEW MEXICO NEWS SERVICES 8/24/26
Party in power has the greatest opportunity for corruption
By Sherry Robinson
All She Wrote
Big black headlines, usually reserved for natural disasters or political upsets, announced, “Sheryl Williams Stapleton found guilty on all counts.”
We could see it coming. When the best defense your lawyer can come up with is that you stole from your co-defendant and not taxpayers, you’re in big trouble.
Many wonder why Stapleton would risk everything on what the AP described as “a yearslong scheme to divert money from public schools to a friend’s company in exchange for kickbacks.” She had everything – a great job with Albuquerque Public Schools and an important post as the long-time House Majority Leader. She used both positions to steer school and state business to an educational software company owned by an old buddy. Both were convicted in the same trial of stealing money from state and federal governments.
Old reporters like me have seen it before. Power, influence and ego metastasize as entitlement and rationalization: “I deserve this.” Their inflated sense of self-importance shields them from the notion they might get caught.
They are floating above the rubes – that is, you and me.
Now cue up the chorus of curmudgeons who will proclaim our state legislators are “all crooks.” In truth, for every lawmaker who finds a way to make a buck, ten more step down because they can no longer afford to serve. Most in our unpaid “citizen legislature” lose money because they’re self-employed or take leave from their jobs to serve. Expenses exceed per diem.
Besides the financial sacrifice is the personal sacrifice. Several people come to mind.
Beginning in 2009 House Speaker Ben Lujan (father of our U.S. senator), was away from his duties without explanation. He was quietly getting cancer treatment because he didn’t want his illness to cloud legislative business. People noticed his absence. Rumors rumbled. He went public in an unforgettable opening-day speech in 2012.
“I’ve learned that being diagnosed with a chronic condition, like cancer, can happen to anyone,” he said. “I have seen firsthand the importance of access to health care for all.”
Lujan stayed in the saddle through the session. He died that year.
In 2011 Rep. Jeanette Wallace, R-Los Alamos, her face gray from sickness, was in her 20th year of service. It was her vote that moved a brutally hard-fought budget in a divided House. With her death after the session, Republican moderates in the Roundhouse went extinct.
And there was Rep. Abbas Akhil, D-Albuquerque, who was proud to become the first Muslim to serve in the Legislature in 2019. As an engineer and scientist, he was a valuable fellow. He stepped down after one term because he was missing too much family time, a problem they all have.
While we’re on the subject of public corruption, we should acknowledge that New Mexico’s decision to not pay legislators can lead to dubious decisions and really bad legislation. Rep. Marion Mathews, D-Albuquerque, said this year that as volunteers “we don’t have a lot of strict ethics rules. A ton of money flows to legislators because the rules are so weak.”
In this atmosphere of looking the other way, the Legislature’s trial lawyers, all Democrats, were able to pass a law that benefits themselves and not us rubes. Since 2021 they’ve been harvesting money from doctors, who are leaving the state in droves. (Like everybody else, I’ve waited months this year to see a specialist. I don’t feel served by this law. Do you?)
Here’s the big takeaway: The party in power has the greatest opportunity – and the most cover – for self-dealing. This leads us to tandem denials by both parties. The Democrats see nothing amiss in Santa Fe and point to blatant graft in Washington D.C. The Republicans don’t talk about D.C. and want you to think all the corruption is in Santa Fe. The only difference is that in Santa Fe corruption is prosecuted, at least some of the time.
Either way, the rubes are paying.
© 2026 NEW MEXICO NEWS SERVICES 8/10/26
Revealing Epstein’s sorry sojourn in New Mexico
By Sherry Robinson
All She Wrote
We value privacy so much in New Mexico it’s a personal ethic. That’s the first of four reasons why Jeffrey Epstein’s activities at the Zorro Ranch could go undetected for years.
Epstein bought 10,000 acres in southern Santa Fe County from the family of former Gov. Bruce King in 1993. The parcel sits on a lonesome stretch of NM 41 between Galisteo and Stanley. He didn’t raise public eyebrows until 1995.
“Build a 30,000-square-foot house in the middle of WayOutThere, call it the Zorro Ranch, and people are bound to notice,” wrote Shonda Novak, of the Albuquerque Tribune, in June 1995. Epstein told her “It’s just a normal home.” He also said, “I’m pretty much of a hermit.”
Epstein shared that his New York friends thought New Mexico was “somewhat desolate,” but he thought New Mexico was “the prettiest, most spectacular state by a long shot.”
He was “very security conscious.” Novak reported: “Current and former Zorro ranch hands say they have been sworn to secrecy. And some say they have been required to sign confidentiality agreements barring them from discussing details about the project or its owner.”
Locals were also tight-lipped.
“We just don’t interfere in people’s lives out here,” said a merchant. “We help people out when they want it, but when they want to be left alone, we leave them alone.”
Epstein isn’t the first rico or movie star to gravitate here for the isolation and privacy. We’ve accommodated many such people seeking refuge from the limelight.
By September 1995, Steve Terrell, of the Santa Fe New Mexican, had learned more. Epstein’s palace was twice the size of the county’s largest home. Epstein was a money manager from Manhattan who practiced yoga, shopped at Wild Oats, and bought $600 bed sheets.
“They’re nice people,” a local builder said. “They should be a welcome participant in the economy of New Mexico.”
Welcoming the money is reason number two that Epstein could fly beneath the radar. His financial spigot funded many a worthy cause and political campaign. This got sticky in 2006 when Florida police accused Epstein of having “sex with five teenagers as young as 14 in his Palm Beach home after luring them to give him massages.” Some politicos, including Gov. Bill Richardson, had to give Epstein’s political contributions to charity.
Reason number three is that we tend to be innocents. Realtor Pat French told Terrell that in the early ‘90s she was trying to help Epstein find a suitable property and stopped by the high-end resort where he was staying. Epstein had at least three teenage girls with him, about the age of her own daughter. “I just assumed they were his daughters,” French said.
This is the backdrop to the legislative Truth Commission investigating Epstein and Zorro Ranch. Created by the House this year, the commission just released its first report. One nagging question: Why did Epstein get a pass here from 2006 until he died in jail in 2019?
According to the report, Epstein became a convicted sex offender with a 2008 plea deal but didn’t have to register as a sex offender in New Mexico because of a loophole in state law. Law enforcement never searched his ranch for firearms, forbidden to a felon. That might have uncovered evidence of sex trafficking.
Which brings us to reason number four: Friends in high places thanks to generous political contributions.
“What we’ve seen is there may have been preferential treatment to Epstein as he came and went to New Mexico,” said Rep. Andrea Romero, D-Santa Fe, who chairs the commission.
As sensitive and closely watched as the commission’s work is, we might expect it to tread carefully around politics, but we’ve seen some missteps.
Senate Minority Leader Bill Sharer, R-Farmington, and Senate Republicans demanded that the commission interrogate gubernatorial candidate Deb Haaland and U.S. Rep. Melanie Stansbury. Haaland once rode on a plane alleged to be owned by Epstein. This is old and debunked. The Senate Rs accuse Stansbury of maybe having a former employer with possible links to Ghislaine Maxwell. Said Stansbury, “False and libelous.” If Sharer really wanted to help, she said, he’d use his influence to get the U.S. Department of Justice to cooperate.
Stansbury has already met with the commission and supports its work.
Now the commission’s two Republican members complain that Romero hasn’t kept them in the loop and that edits were made to the report without their knowledge. They want the Haaland plane ride included in their investigation.
So is it political to delete Haaland’s much discussed plane ride or political to include it? For the sake of purity and clean hands, they should include it. And although Romero thought she was communicating well with her fellow commissioners, she needs to try harder.
This is not about tallying the number of Rs and Ds in its pages. It’s about following the facts, wherever they lead.
© 2026 NEW MEXICO NEWS SERVICES 8/3/26
CYFD sending kid alone across border violates our sense of right and wrong
By Sherry Robinson
All She Wrote
Two days after CYFD assured the public that it was successfully addressing its high caseloads and recruiting new foster families, a story broke that the state agency charged with protecting children walked a teenager to the Mexican border and ordered him to rejoin his mother in Juarez. The mother he hadn’t lived with in nine years. The mother deported by Texas on drug charges. The mother CYFD first said was abusive but then reversed itself to force reunification. The mother CYFD claimed to have vetted by phone.
CYFD sent the teen, a U.S. citizen with a heart condition, across the bridge at night to meet his mother. He bolted and ran across three lanes of traffic toward El Paso, where he spent 10 days in a homeless shelter before Texas and Mexican authorities took him to Juárez.
We see again and again that the state Children Youth and Families Department doesn’t just have staffing and program issues, its decision makers come up short on common sense and common decency. However, the newly created Office of the Child Advocate alerted the state’s Attorney General, who has sued to get the boy returned to New Mexico. The governor’s spokesman defended CYFD and attacked the AG.
My dad used to talk to us about “right and wrong.” To him it was that simple – no shades of grey. This incident violates most people’s sense of right and wrong. Both candidates for governor get that, even if the governor doesn’t.
Republican Gregg Hull told the Albuquerque Journal: “If my administration allowed this to happen, and I didn’t know about it, I’d step out and own it. The buck stops with the Governor’s Office.”
He added, “I can think of one policy that needs to be implemented immediately: Never turn over a 15-year-old at the international border unescorted.”
Hull, a three-term mayor of Rio Rancho, said it was necessary to understand who made the decisions and why. “If the Governor’s Office and the Attorney General’s Office were informed about this, why did they ultimately let this go forward?”
On his website, Hull calls for clear standards, accountability, caseload limits for caseworkers, modern data systems, and safety first in placements.
Democrat Deb Haaland, a former Interior Secretary and congresswoman, said in a news release: “The decision to send a child across the border alone is unacceptable. My heart breaks every time a child is harmed because of poor policy. Kids need to be kept safe and right now CYFD fails to meet that responsibility.”
For some time, Haaland has promised an “overhaul” of CYFD. She’s said she would appoint a qualified secretary and direct them to increase staff, rebuild partnerships and standardize foster recruitment and certification. That’s fine, but she also proposes restructuring CYFD. Instead of being a state agency with a cabinet secretary who answers to the governor, it would be under an independent commission.
Haaland and Hull both get points for stating clearly that what happened here is wrong, something the governor notably didn’t do, but Haaland’s desire to give CYFD more independence is misguided.
In April the state Department of Justice released a 216-page report after investigating CYFD for a year. The report described a department that operates in isolation and avoids accountability. It routinely resists or ignores requests from law enforcement, courts, the Legislature and the public. There is no transparency. Further separation would only make this worse.
Maralyn Beck, who leads the New Mexico Child First Network, is the state’s most credible watchdog. She has warned against removing CYFD from the governor’s control. In an April op-ed she wrote that serving children requires CYFD to work closely with other departments, and that requires having the same bureaucratic parents.
“(I)t’s worth mentioning that not one other state has removed its child welfare department from its governor’s office,” Beck wrote. “Not one. Nada. Zilch.”
Beck said she understands how impatient and desperate we are for change. “But, as someone working in this space daily, I also know that the last thing this agency needs is more uncertainty and instability.
“Solutions exist — but please, this isn’t it. There is a fragile balance here, and lives are at stake. Do not be shortsighted on this. We don’t need to separate CYFD from the governor’s control. What we need is a governor who takes more control by taking to heart the chain reaction and interconnectedness of all child-serving agencies.”
Candidate Deb Haaland, are you listening?